| When There Really Isn’t Enough Milk |
|
|
| Sunday, 08 January 2012 00:00 |
|
I NEED to start off this article by pointing out that a true breast milk supply issue is extremely rare. Most experts estimate that around 1% of women have true low milk supply. Having said this for those in the 1% this issue is serious, and can be devastating. Best Intentions When I became pregnant with my first baby I knew I was going to breastfeed. This wasn’t even a question for me. My mother had breastfed me, and I grew up thinking it was normal to breastfeed. I looked down on mother’s who used formula, and assumed there was never a good enough reason to not breastfeed. I also knew I was going to have a natural birth. Birth to me also seemed normal. I had the right ideas in general, and was a very well intentioned mother, but I was woefully ignorant about the challenges I was going to face in motherhood. Disappointing Circumstances I planned a home birth, but due to circumstances beyond my control had to transport to the hospital and ended up with a birth far from what I wanted. I took my sweet newborn baby home from the hospital tired beyond belief, in lots of pain, and had little help. I thought the breastfeeding was going well. He nursed 24 hours a day around the clock, but I had heard newborns could be like this and wasn’t concerned. He didn’t cry almost at all, and seemed perfect. My mom called me on the 3rd day and asked if my milk had come in yet. I told her no, and that it still looked like colostrum to me. She said not to worry, that it would come soon, and I really wasn’t worried. Worrying Something’s Wrong On the 5th day I realized that things seemed odd to me. My breasts didn’t feel full, he was still nursing 24/7, and I had no signs that my milk had, “come in”. His check up revealed that he had lost a considerable amount of birth weight, and my pediatrician was urging me at this point to supplement with formula. Convinced that we didn’t have a problem I left very frustrated, and didn’t give him any formula. My pro breastfeeding pediatrician agreed to watch and see for a while, but urged me to come in every other day to weigh him. 2 days later I took my sweet baby in. He had lost even more weight. He also hadn’t had a bowel movement in 3 days, and his diapers were barely ever wet. It was clear to my pediatrician he wasn’t getting enough. I was still stubborn though. He hardly cried, and he looked healthy to me, and I was set in my ways. Realizing There’s a Real Problem Again I ignored her, and didn’t supplement him with formula, but I did consult several lactations consultants, and began taking measures to increase my milk supply. A few days later it was clear to me there was a problem. My little baby seemed lethargic, and was starting to look sickly. He still hadn’t had a bowel movement, and I had that sinking feeling that we really did have a big problem. I took him back to his pediatrician. I was hoping I was wrong and just overreacting, but the scale said otherwise. Again he’d lost weight. An initial weight drop in a newborn is not at all uncommon, but he should have been gaining by now [most babies lose about 10% of their birth weight, but begin gaining it back by the 10th day]. The First Formula Feed The pediatrician wanted to admit him to the hospital, he was so dehydrated. I couldn’t bear the thought of seeing my baby hooked up to an IV, and I begged her to wait and see first. She agreed to let me wait in her office for a couple of hours of observation while I gave him a bottle of formula. I had been nursing him for several hours non stop. He guzzled down 3 ounces of formula (a lot for a newborn), and fell into a deep and peaceful sleep. I couldn’t believe it, for the first time since he was born he wasn’t latched onto me. No More Breast Milk I continued to seek help from lactation consultants, and was using a breast pump and herbs in an attempt to increase my milk supply. Unfortunately though by about 2 months my milk had dried up entirely and that was the end of our breastfeeding relationship. I felt horrible. I had tons of guilt over not giving him my own milk. Pregnant Again When my son was 14 months old I discovered I was pregnant again. I was so excited to have another baby, but this time was so nervous about the birth and breastfeeding. I planned another home birth, and this time began preparing much earlier to see if I couldn’t have a full milk supply this time. I bought some books on breastfeeding (The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding is my favorite), and began attending La Leche League meetings regularly. I was confident this time could be different. A Better Birth My daughter’s birth went perfectly! I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect, peaceful, beautiful home birth then the one I had. I was elated. She latched on and nursed like a champ, and I thought this time we wouldn’t have a problem. Like her brother she nursed around the clock, but this didn’t alarm me, as I know babies like to nurse. Around day five, I realized that I didn’t feel like my milk had come in, but she seemed fine, and though she had lost some birth weight it was still on the lower end of normal. She wasn’t passing as much stool as I had hoped, but I still kept hoping my milk would come in that night. Recurring Problem On the 6th night my daughter was restless. She nursed, then cried, then nursed, then cried. My midwife came a few hours earlier and was concerned about the weight loss, and lack of soiled diapers. She left me with a syringe to give her formula milk with (just in case). My daughter’s crying continued for hours, and at 3 am my husband asked me what was wrong. I said I really don’t think there’s enough milk. He went to the drug store and bought a can of formula, and I cried as I dribbled it into her mouth. I felt like a huge failure. Trying to Increase Breast Milk In the morning I was on the phone with my local La Leche League leader, my midwife, and IBCLC lactation consultant. I began my routine of pumping, herbs, and even tried heavier prescription meds (reglan) to increase my milk supply. Nothing worked. I was making about 4-6 ounces of breast milk a day. Enough for about 2 of my newborns feeds. Our daily routine went like this. My daughter would nurse for a long time, about 30 minutes, and then pull off frustrated; I would give her any milk that I had pumped, then give her formula until she was full; then I’d rest for an hour and go pump breast milk for about 30 minutes. My daughter was usually ready for her next nursing session about an hour after I’d pumped and the cycle continued. Diagnosing the Problem I had more milk for my daughter then I did my son. I was so determined, but I never got anywhere near a full supply. Finally, my midwife and lactation consultant told me that I had Insufficient Glandular Tissue. Around puberty my breasts just didn’t develop enough glandular tissue to feed my baby. There was nothing I could do other then what I’d already done. Alternative Feeding Once I had realized that I did everything I could, my guilt went away. I knew before God that I had done everything in my power to give my baby the best. I had a friend and doula client that knew about my supply issues. She offered to pump breast milk for me when her baby came, and let me tell you she had lots of milk! I was so relieved to be giving my daughter breast milk instead of formula! Then I found out about a local Facebook based group, Human Milk for Human Babies, which seeks to match moms in need of milk with moms that have plenty of extra frozen expressed breast milk. I began to get donations from other mom’s, and my daughter was getting about 90% breast milk and 10% formula. I was so happy, and am still so grateful for all the moms that worked hard to feed my daughter. Supplemental Nursing System Since my daughter’s birth my knowledge about breastfeeding has grown even more. I honestly think I did a really good job with keeping the supply I did have with my daughter. There is only one other thing I wish I had tried. Something called an SNS (Supplemental Nursing System). It’s basically a bottle that goes around your neck with a tube that attaches to your breast so the baby can still get the supplement at your breast rather than from a bottle. Here is my advice: If you think you have an insufficient milk supply talk to a lactation consultant ASAP! Don’t wait, call immediately! I have TONS of advice to give, but each situation is different, and it’s important that you get first-hand expert advice. Please keep in mind that not all lactation consultants are equal in their education, and you need to seek out the best of the best. I highly recommend that you consult an IBCLC (International Board Certified Lactation Consultant). These lactation consultants are highly trained and are able to distinguish the difference between a low milk supply that can be easily corrected, and a mother who is truly medically unable to obtain a full supply of breast milk. If you are unaware of an IBCLC in your area turn to the internet, and find one from elsewhere. If you truly need to supplement your baby, consider using breast milk from another mother. I would ask close friends and family first, but if no one is able, consider asking for help through a local branch of the Human Milk for Human Babies Global Network. (Read the article Human Milk for Human Babies on Saudi Life for more information about the Saudi branch.) I thought about just writing a research based article rather than giving you my full breastfeeding history, but I remember how alone I felt when I really and truly was not making enough breast milk. You probably can’t even imagine how hard I worked to give my babies the best. Helpful Resources Al Bidayah Center offers breastfeeding support in Jeddah and has plans to open an office in Riyadh as well. If you are in the Americas, search IBLCE in the Americas. For general support, consider attending a La Leche League meeting. The Al Bidayah Center hosts La Leche League meetings in Jeddah and there is an also an online Yahoo group for mothers in the Middle East called La Leche League in the Middle East. In Riyadh, there is an informal group, Circle of Nurturing, comprised of several breastfeeding counselors. They host monthly breastfeeding support and social meetings and are available to meet with mothers in need. You can contact the Motherhood Column Editor, Aisha Al Hajjar, for more information. Rare Problem Although many mothers have difficulty with breastfeeding at first, it really is rare to have a problem that cannot be overcome with determination and diligence. I hope there aren’t many out there who go through what I went through, but if your story is similar to mine know you are not alone. All the best! Dayle Student Midwife and Doula |


STACEY GREAVES-FAVORS












Comments
I admire your determination when others would have given up much sooner, and I also applaud you giving breastmilk even though it wasnt your own. I hope one day your daughter is proud that her momma was looking out for her.
warmly,
Nirgaz
Very well written article, thank you.
I really can't see anywhere in the article where she implies that she looks down on mothers who do not breastfeed. As Muslimahs, it is our obligation to try to provide breastmilk for our children, per Allah as state in the Quran, but certainly their is no judgement expressed here. As a mother who also struggles to make enough, and a midwife who supports hundreds of mothers who nurse their babies, I am well aware that producing milk and nursing children is an enormous responsibility, and one that comes with trials and tribulations for most women. Each family situation is unique and so it is not always possible, or desired by a mother, but it is in fact what Allah designed us to do. For anyone woman who feels overwhelmed by the job, please know that there are so many wonderful resources available to you. Even is you have suffered a difficult birth, are experiencing postpartum depression, or a feeling a general disinterest in parenting due to trauma, lack of support, or other factors, you have a wide community waiting to help you through it. La Leche League is a great place to start.
Thanks for this great article, sis! Two of my three babies were exclusively donor milk fed.
Jazak Allah KHair
At Dayla,
It really isn't. All you showed is that in order to uplift yourself you needed to put others down. I wish, I knew you in person.
Dear Ruth, For some people breastfeeding is super easy. Many women have little to no difficulty, and then others of us struggle. There are physiological, environmental, and emotional reasons for these struggles. I too was not prepared enough for early motherhood. This is common though, and most of us learn through our experiences. I hope that your next breastfeeding experience will go much more smoothly. There is help out there, and it’s very important that we make use of it.
I agree with you that Dayle has put her statement wrong that she looks down at mothers who formula feed their children but i think more than offending any one it was made to show her immense belief in the goodness of breast milk. And yes you are right, Although Allah commands us in the Quran Surah baqarah ayah 223 "THE MOTHERS SHALL BREASTFEED THEIR OFFSPRINGS FOR TWO WHOLE YEARS.......NO ONE SHOULD BE CHARGED WITH MORE THAN THEY CAN AFFORD.NEITHER A MOTHER SHOULD BE MADE TO SUFFER ON ACCOUNT OF HER CHILD NOR A FATHER ON ACCOUNT OF HIS CHILD..." Although it is commanded but it is not Obligatory and absolutely not sinful if the parents decide not to. But then, nevertheless every gulp would be a sadaqah (InshaAllah) because of the immense patience it requires.
But hey come on let us not judge the site due to this error :)
I personally think It is a wonderful and very informative site..
@ Khadijah and Dayla: I am quite aware that breastmilk is best because its stated on the formula containers I purchase for my child. But, I also never disagreed with Dayla ( who I find and still find to be quite arrogant and prideful but I look forward to the Day of Judgment when you are slapped down into the hellfire for your ARROGANCE.)
with Respect to Khadijah and Sadia: Thanks for your replies and even though I hate putting my personal information on the web, I do have intentions of breastfeeding my future children InshAllaah. I even breast fed my current child until some things went wrong that I rather not discuss with strangers(sorry ) and already, I sense their is a lack of empthany from mothers who breastfeed to mothers who don't.
And Sadia, I often hear( well really read) that one reason why breastfeeding mothers don't like or look down on mothers who formula feed is because "we are suppose to be lazy parents" well from my understanding most breastfeeding mothers during the night just simply put the child on the breast and fall back to sleep. As a formula mom, I wish I could simply stick the bottle in my child's mouth and fall back to sleep but I can't. I must fully wake up or else I might drop my precious baby, feed him, burp him, change his diaper and rock him back to sleep (some nights he don't go back to sleep so I stay up until he does with no help from my husband). This requries patience as well.
I think, I have given this article enough of my attention for the day...I have an adorable formula fed baby who I must attend to. Best of Luck Khadjiah and Sadia. May Allaah reward you with good in this life as well as the next. Ameen.
Take care.
To Dayle's defense about how she previously "looked down on" mothers who fed their babies formula...it was just that...a previous judgement...one that she no longer holds. She learned, the hard way, that not all mothers can breastfeed and in the process gained a new perspective and compassion for those who cannot, or even chose not to breast feed. I've had these discussions with Dayle many times over, and can tell you that while she believes breast milk is the best for a baby (and by and large all pediatricians and health organizations agree) she also realizes that women do have options and the freedom to choose what works best for them and their lifestyle. Dayle no longer looks down on anyone for feeding a bottle of formula to a baby, but she does advocate for women who cannot breast feed to search out mothers with plenty to share.
And from a personal standpoint, when I was nursing my babies in the 1980's, I was the "odd one" and looked down on. As women with babies, shouldn't we just come around each other and support each other no matter what choices we make? Motherhood is HARD and rather than tear each other down, let's lift one another up...cheer each other on in this journey of motherhood. We have enough difficulties to face each day already.
So to all of you younger moms reading this, I say "Good job! Keep doing everything you know to do to the best of your ability. Some days you'll make mistakes...sometimes big ones...but it's ok. Your children will still love you for doing the best you can to love them. Take some time each day for yourself! You need to replenish the energy you spend on your children when they are so little so you can continue being the best mom you can be. Give yourself some grace and understand that you will not be a perfect mother. Be willing to admit that to your children when they are older. They will forgive you and they will admire you for being honest and open. Tell your children every day how much you love them and hug them hard. Call another mom and tell her she's doing a good job. Call your mother or another older woman and ask for advice, or just vent. She's been down that road and will understand. Enjoy the journey too. It's not always enjoyable, but enjoy the moments you can and journal all those crazy things your children say and do or capture them on video. I wish I had. Motherhood is a beautiful, hard, priceless, yet sometimes thankless, job. In the end, when they are adults, it pays back in amazing ways."
Dayle, you're a wonderful mother and you are a true blessing to me. I love you so much and can't wait to give you a big hug the next time I get to see you.
P.S. (Sorry this is so long...) I was at Dayle's second birth. It was the most glorious day watching my daughter give birth to her daughter. The added fun was that her daughter weighed and measured exactly the same that Dayle did when she was born, and both labors were incredibly short.
Ameen to ur dua .. But with all due respect a kind reminder for all of us that indeed all Judgement is for Allah Alone. Who will be slapped and who will not be is only for Him to decide, if we r hurt we leave it to Him to decide the matter..i think that is what patience is all about.
And look at the ordeal Dayle had to go through..!! But she emerged guiltless because she knew she tried.. Thats it.. We all decide whats the best for our children.so the whole point is as long as the children are healthy its all fine InshaAllah..
Dear Dayle
JazakAllah Khair! Im sure there might be women facing a similar situation and inshAllah might benefit from your article a great deal!
May AllahSwt keep you and your family happy in both the worlds! :)
@ Nasirah
I guess you haven't realized the seriousness of what you said. Please do realize that you are only a human being and can never know about the "arrogance" of another human being simply because you are not Allah(Glorified be He). And neither is any human being given the right to decide if another human being is going to Paradise or Hell.
For your own benefit my sister in Islaam I suggest you take some time off and sincerely reflect about what you wrote.
Is AllahSwt going to pleased with you for insulting and accusing a Muslim sister of yours and that too publicly on the internet?
Even if you felt like she was on the wrong, don't you think there was a better way to write down your thoughts and also pray for her goodness instead of her doom?
Please read or listen to lectures about the dangers of accusing and insulting another Muslim.
May AllahSwt guide and forgive us all and protect us from the evil within our ownselves!
You are absoloutely correct "thinktwicebefor e youspeak" so I stand correct and I shall rectified my condition with Allaah but my response was an reaction that I and many other women who formula feed feel on daily basis. I personally isolated myself during the first month and half after starting my son on formula because I didnot want to be seen in public feeding my child formula because I knew I would get disgusted looks on top of the disgusted looks I receive on a daily basises ( I am a niqabi living in the United States of America). So again, I apologize to Dayla, and anyone else I offended. I know I said that I would not come back on but I needed to correct my wronging.
and to Kim, thank you for your elderly ( I am not calling you old) words of wisdom. Yes, I do agree as formula and breast feeding we should be able to get along and probably would if we never known each other opinions or situations.
:) I cant tell you how happy I am now!
SubhanAllah, it's indeed the shaytan that tries to cause rift between people.
MashAllah tabarakAllah, to be a niqabi in the west aint easy! May AllahSWT keep you steadfast and strong for His Sake Alone!
Hey whenever you feel like someone is putting you down just focus your attention to the benefits and rewards you'll receive in this world and the next and I bet you will feel happy and not frustrated, becz I have tried doing that :)
May AllahSWT grant us all easy entry into His Jannah!
I wasn't aware of the donor milk system you referred to. I'm wondering how do people who use donor milk for their babies keep track of the donor moms, as it has implications in forming foster relationships in Islam (also the issue of families becoming mahram to the child fed with donated milk from another woman).
Lastly Nasirah, my sister feeds her children formula because many of them are foster or adopted. I NEVER judge mom’s who formula feed. I don’t know what led them to this, and never, ever would. I know the pain of being judged all too well! THAT is why I wrote this article. Thank you for retracting your words, you are very much forgiven. I will pray that we ALL meet in heaven one day.
Masha’Allah, as the editor of the Motherhood column I am pleased to see that this article has evoked such passion.
Personally, I was thrilled to share Dayle’s story. I know her well and she is a dear colleague and friend (as are all the writers of this column). We all share the same passion for natural birth and breastfeeding because we strongly believe in the perfect design of our Creator. At the same time we are supportive of women in general. Our goals are to share our experience and ensure that women have the information to make informed choices.
Our job is to put the education is out there. Women have the right to make whatever choice is best for them and our goal is always healthy mother and healthy baby, regardless of whether the decisions made match our own personal values or not.
Having said that, I think it’s become clear through comments that there was some misunderstandin gs of the intent of this article. The whole point was to show support for mothers who do not breastfeed, regardless the reason, as none of us walk in her shoes nor are faced with her challenges.
Dayle learned a valuable lesson from her experience and was gracious enough to share it with the world. It saddened me to see her attacked by her Muslim sister, but I am pleased to see it resolved with humility, masha’Allah.
I truly believe that ALL mothers do the best they can with the information they have at the time and ALL mothers who would even take the time to read such a column are looking for the best for their baby, masha’Allah. There’s no dispute, scientifically nor religiously, that breast is the best nutritional option for our babies...however, for some mothers and for some babies, formula truly is better for their individual circumstances.
I am grateful that there is a substitute available for those families that need it, whether that be for medical reasons, emotional reasons, biological reasons, logistical reasons, and most of all PERSONAL reasons.
My goal as editor of the Motherhood column is to help educate women so that they can get the information they need to make informed decisions. It is not meant to judge any one in particular nor any group for their decisions.
In fact, I invite anyone with a story idea to submit it. If the writing is of good quality and the information evidence based, I am very pleased to feature it as a guest submission.
May Allah bring peace and harmony and love between sisters for the sake of Allah.
Best regards,
-Aisha, Natural Mom
Even when I have a peace about my lack of milk supply, I am flooded with judgmental comments from mothers (and fathers) who simply do not believe its possible to have a low milk supply. I have gotten remarks in the drug store while buying a can of formula "I can't believe you aren't breast feeding your baby!" Countless others have told me how I won't ever be able to bond with my sweet son unless I breast feed. I am just as bonded as any other Mother and son, thank you!
Thank you for putting this possibility out there for people to read. I will talk to my oB about this diagnosis and see what she thinks. :)
I pray you have a better experience next time, be it breast or bottle or a combination of the two. At least you will be prepared from this last experience, should breastfeeding simply not be an option for you.
This article, and your story is a perfect example of why judgment should be kept out of the baby feeding arena (and all of life’s issues, frankly). One never knows what tests and circumstances are occurring in the life of another.
Islamically speaking, if we feel disappointment or judgment coming upon us with regards to our sisters (or brothers), we are to stop and ponder at least 70 excuses for them. This serves to soften our heart and helps us put ourselves in the shoes (so-to-speak) of the other person as we reframe our initial reaction of judgment, to one of compassion and understanding.
This is a great reminder for those moms who are so passionate about breastfeeding that they snap to judge others (or so passionate about their feeding choice that they snap to retort back).
1. Maybe she doesn’t have enough milk
2. Maybe she is on medication that contraindicates nursing
3. Maybe her baby is adopted
4. Maybe she isn’t even the mother (care provider, mother dead or in jail or in hospital)
5. Maybe she never learned the benefits of nursing and truly thinks formula is better
6. Maybe the baby is ill and needs special feeding
7. Maybe the mother had breast surgery
8. Maybe it’s the mother’s own milk in the bottle and she is just too modest to feed in public
9. Maybe the mother suffered postpartum depression and couldn’t emotionally tolerate nursing
10. Maybe the baby had a tongue tie and couldn’t get a good latch
11. Maybe the baby was premie and in the hospital for months and they bottle fed him in NICU and he got nipple confused and never could get latched to the breast after that
etc. etc. etc.
Best regards,
-Aisha, Natural Mom
But I'd like to suggest to the author and the editor that they do not publish such outrageous comments in the future. I think it's better to delete them than to reply. They do more harm than good. You're actually being good to the commenter by not publishing his/her sin and by not allowing it to affect others.
I'm sure we all have no problem in accepting constructive criticism, if it's respectful. But when that criticism is a personal attack and lacks basic Islamic etiquette and manners, please get rid of it, and advise the commenter in private.
Regarding what the commenter said, I find it necessary to quote the hadeeth:
Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said, 'Once someone said, 'By Allah! Allah will not forgive such and such (a person).' Thereupon, Allah, the Exalted and the Glorious, said, 'Who is he, who takes an oath in My Name that I will not grant pardon to so-and-so? I have granted pardon to so-and-so and rendered your good deeds fruitless.'' [Saheeh Muslim]
I pray that she realizes the tremendous error she has made and begs for Allah's forgiveness and the writer's as well. I say this wishing good for her.
Regards
Trying to connect with you on Facebook, but can't figure out how. Please reach out to me on Facebook (Sabriyya Abdur-Rauf)insha'Allah regarding your midwifery studies. I really enjoyed our time together at the conference.
Ma'a Salaama,
Sr. Sabriyya
RSS feed for comments to this post